Piano Acumen

to inspire and inform.....

  • About
  • Reviews
    • Course pack reviews
      • Learn and Master Piano
      • Yousician for piano
      • Piano for All
    • Online Tuition
      • Shawn Cheek’s webpianoteacher.
      • Playground Sessions
  • Blog
  • Suggested reading
  • Suggested Listening
  • Resources
  • Pianoacumen Links
  • Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy

HDpianio – a review from a member

November 29, 2018 By Dave F 1 Comment

“HDpiano is a great learning platform. High quality HD videos of many songs from a wealth of artists, presented in a clear and informative manner, make this a valuable tool for learning songs on the piano.”

Please note I have no affiliation to HDpiano and will receive no compensation for my review. These are my unbiased views and experiences.

Price: $15 a month or $97 a year.

Payment : Credit card or PayPal.

Guarantee – Free 30 day trial. Will refund subscription if contacted within 7 days.

Requirements: Either piano, keyboard or midi keyboard. PC, MAC or Tablet.

What you get as a subscriber? : Many hours of Songs split into parts. Videos can be looped, slowed down and skipped to chosen sections.

Pros:

  • Highly efficient and excellent playback quality.
  • Modern and classical songs.
  • Wealth of material from many artists to suit all ability levels.
  • First part is available free on YouTube.
  • Search function makes it easy to find songs or artists.
  • Can search by difficulty, genre, decade, song title or artist.
  • Access to sheet music if desired at a small cost.
  • No need to read music.

Cons:

  • Some well-known artists such as Billy Joel, Elton John, Abba are not present, although permission from the artists being sought.
  • Aimed more at learning songs, a few lessons on YouTube. If you are a learner, you may need separate tuition elsewhere.

Suitable For: Beginners, intermediates and advanced.

Course content : ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Tutor knowledge/skill : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Customer support : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Value for Money : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Acumen rating : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

What is HDpiano?

If you’ve searched for piano music videos online or via YouTube, there’s a good chance you have come across HDpiano hybrid piano lessons. It started in 2012 inspired by a computer game.

They use a Synthesia style tool which is a scrolling conveyor above a keyboard. The lights on the conveyor show you the keys to press and the length of the light represents how long you hold the note. If you’ve seen dancing arcade games or have played rockband on the xbox/PlayStation you may be familiar with the concept.

It’s different from Yousician as you are seeing the notes appear vertically instead of horizontally. It may not suit everyone’s taste, but I find it very effective. I regard myself as an intermediate player, so when I see an advanced piece with lots of notes, I do feel a little daunted. This is natural, so dont set your sites too high initially and be put off.

Similar to Shawn Cheek’s webpiano teacher, each song is broken down into parts. Sometimes these can be as simple as the intro, verse, chorus and bridge. Part one, usually the intro, is available free on YouTube and if you want to learn the complete song, you have to enroll as a member. There are many YouTube videos of their lessons, so why not subscribe to their channel to see what’s on offer. As I write they have over a million subscribers on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/user/HDPiano

What do you see when you log-on?

Once you have logged in, you are presented with a dashboard, which includes a menu to the left and videos on the main page. The first time you log on, the videos are the latest lessons of songs to be published. When you have browsed some videos and saved some favourites, you will also see a video history of your previous visits. This is useful if you want to jump straight back in to a lesson.

The menu includes a home option to get you back to the dashboard (this can also be accessed at any time by selecting the HDpiano logo at the top left).

The history and favourite options do what you would expect taking you to a list of previous videos.

You have the option to view and edit your account preferences, such as changing your email or password.

Resources include a welcome tour video, instructions on how you can loop or slow down the videos as well as study tips and technical tips such as turning on subtitles.

Finally, there is a FAQ and contact page. The FAQs are worth a quick read to familiarise yourself with website and their policies.

What is included in the content?

As I write there a 901 song lessons, so take a look at the diverse artists available.

  • Alicia Keys,
  • Sam Smith,
  • David Bowie
  • Erik Satie
  • The Doors
  • Chicago
  • The Fray
  • George Ezra
  • Johann Sebastian Bach
  • John Legend,
  • Nina Simone and
  • many more.

I guess I’m showing my age, as there were quite a few artists I hadn’t heard of so, there should be plenty for everyone.

Note there are some omissions from well-known artists such as Adele, Elton John and Billy Joel to name a few. From what I’ve read on their site they are seeking permission from the artists to reproduce their material Although this is slightly frustrating, it does promote a legitimate, honest quality to the site and their teachers. They respect license laws of music artists.

When searching you can filter by

  • Artist
  • Difficulty
  • Decade
  • Teacher and
  • Genre.

These can be sorted alphabetically, by publish date or by popularity.

I had a quick browse and searched for Queen. I’ve recently had a desire to learn “We are the Champions”, so I was pleased to see this included as well as 7 other Queen songs at intermediate and advanced level.

The quality of the video was excellent. The intro was played at normal speed and then the piece was discussed with notes on the rhythm of the left hand and the basic chords. I was very quickly playing the chords and getting a feel for the song and had the first phrase down very quickly with some practice.

The tuition quality impressed me – It’s relaxed and friendly, but quite serious tuition. “We are the Champions” is an intermediate piece, so will take some time and effort to learn.

Check out the video yourself on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiSXs0p3S6Y

About the teachers.

The site is co-owned by Dan Collins. I hadn’t come across him before, but he has been playing the piano since the age of 6. He is a talented, experience musician in his own right and a few recordings of his own playing. I had a listen on Spotify and his talent is clear.

Go here to see a bio of Dan Collins.

As I write there are 18 teachers including Dan. They are on the site in first name terms only, so it’s difficult to get any bio on them. From those I have experienced, they are all very competent and teach in a similar, friendly and effective manner.

They follow the same approach in the website – i.e. breaking down songs into sections and going through each part slowly bringing it up to speed.

The social media element is also very good. In addition to the YouTube channel, there is a Facebook page, a Twitter following and an Instagram page. The teachers try to to engage the social media when they teach and feedback is shown on the page you are on, with comments under the tuition. This is a nice little touch. You could ask a question to another member for example or the teacher will get back to you or engage in a group conversation.

Should I buy/upgrade to a full membership?

I saw a criticism of the fee while researching the site, which I felt was quite harsh. Why pay the monthly $15 fee, when there are free versions of many of the included songs on the internet or YouTube. Fair point, but you won’t necessarily get the quality of tuition from others (with no disrespect to some teachers on YouTube).

The quality of the teaching, video playback, ability to loop or slowdown won’t be found on a standard YouTube video. The quality of the musicians and the accuracy of the music is very impressive to me.

And for $15 a month? How much would a private teacher cost in your area? And for the content available, I think it’s could value. How much does a piece of sheet music cost these days? How much does a song book from a musician cost? If you put into this context $15 a month is good value to me.

I highly recommend HDpiano as a resource for learning songs, especially as an adult. I would always encourage children to learn to read music if possible, as this is a great skill to have, but if reading music is not important to you and you just want to learn songs, this is great. I’ve only given four stars for content as there are a few artists missing, but it’s a minor niggle. There’s so much material here, it will keep you busy for some time.

Good luck. Happy to respond to comments.

Playground Sessions

May 8, 2018 By Dave F 3 Comments

“Playground Sessions is a high quality learning tool with excellent tuition covering most of the necessary skills and techniques. With a huge repertoire of lessons and songs, it makes a worthwhile investment.”

Playground sessions main image

Price:
Monthly package $17.99
Annual package $ 119.88 for first year. $9.99 per month thereafter.
Lifetime package $289.99.

Each package includes 5 free songs a month.

Prices correct as at July 2019.

Credit card only. No PayPal or other methods accepted.
(All prices at the time of writing)

Guarantee – 30 day money back guarantee.

Requirements:
Either piano, keyboard or midi keyboard.
&
Either PC, MAC or Tablet.  (USB or midi leads for connection to your chosen device)

What you get as a subscriber?

“Video Lessons from Harry Connick, Jnr”
“Hours of video tutorials”
“Hundreds of interactive lessons”
“Rhythm, Notation, Play by Ear”
“Rookie, Intermediate, Advances levels”
“Expanded content every month”

Pros:

  • Highly efficient and good quality learning tool.
  • Modern and classical songs as you learn techniques.
  • Additional songs to purchase at various ability levels with good quality playback
    and feedback of your accuracy.
  • Main core of the course is good value.

Cons:

  • Cost to buy additional songs once your free songs have been used up may not appeal to some.

Suitable For: Beginners, intermediates and advanced.

Course content : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Tutor knowledge/skill : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Customer support :⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Value for Money : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Acumen rating ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Playground sessions course content and structure.

When you open the Playground sessions app you are faced with your dashboard.  From here I went to the
“Bootcamp” option and chose the beginners section.

piano sessions dashboard image

In Playground sessions, you will find 78 lessons in front of you which you download one at a time.  Some of these are video tutorials with the teacher, but most are lessons built around a song. The lesson will have a number of parts varying from a few to six. You click on the part and you will hear a count in, before the piece starts. You can adjust the tempo if a piece is difficult. Sometimes there is a brief verbal narrative at the top of the lesson explaining the piece.

In a similar process to Yousician, there is a count-in and the song commences. You must hit the required note in time with the piece.

Unlike Yousician, there is no option, but to learn traditional music script. If this is not your aim, then you may prefer learning via a different medium such as Shawn Cheek’s webpianoteacher.  However, the music learning is not daunting and is built upon very slowly – learning a few notes at a time from the Treble Clef (generally played with the right hand) and Bass Clef (generally played with the left hand).

I like the way the song is built up slowly with more notes being added with each part. It’s also a good challenge to aim for that perfect score of 100

At the end of each part you are presented with a score of accuracy and colour – Green is a pass and you can continue to the next part. Amber or red is a fail and you must start again.

This feedback is essential.  I have mentioned before that having a one-on-one teacher is the best method to learn piano, but if that is not available, having feedback from a machine or tool like Playground is the next best thing.

The song choice is good with a mixture of pop and classical pieces for the beginner

Early songs include

  • The Beatles “I love you”,
  • Frank Sinatra’s “My Way”,
  • Jeff Buckley’s “Hallelujah”,
  • Beethoven’s “Fur Elise” and many more.

Not a nursery rhyme in sight, which is great. To reiterate, with these early songs, you are not generally playing the main theme – more of a simple accompaniment to get you familiar with reading music, learning the notes on the keyboard and keeping in time.

The Intermediate tour continues with the same theme and there are 50 lessons in this section. More complex techniques and theories are explored including

  • Triads,
  • Major & Minor Thirds,
  • Inversions,
  • 8th notes & rests,
  • broken chords,
  • syncopation,
  • transposing to different keys and
  • chord progressions.

Songs include

  • Hey There Delilah,
  • Stairway to Heaven,
  • Chariots of Fire and
  • Boulevard of Broken Dreams…. to name a few.

The Advanced tour has 19 lessons exploring

  • 16th notes,
  • advanced rhythms & arpeggios,
  • major and minor 7th chords and
  • practicing with both hands.

Songs include

  • Piano Man,
  • Stay With Me,
  • All of Me,
  • Moonlight Sonata and
  • Don’t Stop Believin’….

Playground sessions songs.

Piano sessions song library page

The song section boasts over 500 songs. These can be purchased for $3.99 each or $5 for non-members, but most packages have a song or two included.  My first reaction to this was negative. Why should you pay extra for additional songs? Other sites, such as Shawn Cheek require no extras once you are a member.

However the songs on Playground sessions are more than just the sheet music. The song will move as you play and you will be assessed on your accuracy, so you are getting instant feedback. This motivates you to improve and nail a better score each time. You’ll obviously not get any feedback on feel and the dynamics you put into the song. Once you are familiar with the piece, it’s a good idea to record yourself and hear how it sounds.

So what do you get for $3.99? You get access to the interactive piece (with audio), the printed music (3 prints per purchase) and lifetime access to the song via Playground sessions – assuming you are a member.  Even so this is an extra cost that may put some people off.

The songs are split into various categories. Firstly by ability –

  • Rookie,
  • Intermediate or
  • Advanced.

Second by Genre including

  • Classical,
  • Pop,
  • Rock,
  • Holiday,
  • Films/Musicals,
  • Jazz and so on.

There is a third category by “Lesson type” which will split songs with Video tutorials and those songs that have accompaniments. At the time of writing there were 31 songs with video tutorials at various abilities.

Rookie songs include hits from

  • Bryan Adams,
  • Bruno Mars,
  • Coldplay,
  • Vanessa Carlton,
  • Christina Perri,
  • Bill Withers,
  • John Legend,
  • Christina Aguilera,
  • Elton John,
  • ABBA
  • and many more including classical, films and shows.

It’s an exhaustive list which will keep you busy for some-time…. And will cost you a lot if you bought every piece!

Each piece is also described as Easy, Moderate or Hard, even in the Rookie Section, to give some further guidance.

When you click on a piece you are presented with a one page preview of the sheet music and an audio preview of the piece. I clicked on “Don’t stop Believin” from Journey and listened to the preview. This is a simplified version of the song with a bassline and the vocal melody both played on the piano.

However there are more detailed versions in the Intermediate and Advanced sections.  The audio previews both the piano part and the piece with the band accompaniment. I was impressed with the production and standard of the song – I can play the piano part already, but the advanced piece adds to the difficulty with an enhanced vocal line played on the piano during the verses and chorus. So, again, although you are paying $3.99 you are getting more than just the sheet music.

Intermediate and advanced songs include enhanced versions that are found in the rookie section. So in theory you could buy more than three versions of the same song. “Don’t stop Believin’ ” is available as Rookie Moderate, Intermediate Easy, Intermediate Hard and Advanced Moderate – so nearly $16 if you bought all four.  Some songs have even more versions…. I think this could be improved. If you wanted to start from Rookie and progress through all abilities, perhaps a discount could be available or they could be bought as a package?

To summarise the Playground sessions catalogue available, the production quality and the learning process the songs give you are impressive, but I still feel uncomfortable with the extra cost and hence cannot give 5 stars for value. Others may disagree and say $3.99 is good value for a single song with the enhancements you receive, but my point is, these costs can add up over time. Still cheaper than a private tutor sitting with you going through a piece of music? I guess so.

One for the individual to make up their own mind.
Click here to see the full range of Playground sessions songs.

About the tutors.

https://www.playgroundsessions.com/about/instructors

The quality of tuition is very professional with a solid curriculum.  Arrangements are interesting and a good challenge keeping you motivated to progress through the course.

Quincy Jones is a legend in the music industry with a long list of credits and Grammy awards. I guess he is most famous for being producer on Michael Jackson’s three most iconic and successful albums. For him to put his name to anything, it gives an air of quality.

The main teacher is David Sides who you will see and hear throughout the course. I wasn’t aware of him until Playground session and his talent is impressive. The link above will show you 4 of his arrangements which are worth a listen.  His teaching style is relaxed and informative.  He speaks slowly and gets the facts and techniques across very well. His arrangements are also interesting.

Piano sessions example of tuition video

Other involvements include Alex Ness, David Gracia and Dr. Bryon Adams and details can be found at the above link.

Playground sessions – a worthwhile course.

I can’t help but like Playground session’s main learning tool and core. I prefer it to Yousician although there are some close similarities.

The arrangements are good and will keep you motivated. You have no choice but to learn to read music at the same time as you learn the piano, but don’t let this put you off. It’s built upon very slowly learning only a few notes at a time. You will be playing an accompaniment to a well know piece of music with the added motivation to hit that perfect score. You are also notified via a ping when you reach a new level.

I like this feedback and the motivation to reach 100. The content will keep you busy for a long time and I think the core package is very good value.

Piano sessions lesson list

However, the main reason I cannot give this 5 stars is the additional expense of the songs. When you purchase an additional piece, you are buying more than just the sheet music.  You have an accompaniment and feedback to your accuracy.  Taken in a single song, this is valuable, but if you were to purchase all the songs, the costs will mount up.

Maybe I’m being a little harsh, as buying all the songs could be over a few years, so the costs may not be noticeable. There are also sales and discounts at certain times.

Another added feature is the option to buy a keyboard package together with your subscription. This is aimed for at the U.S market it appears. Do your homework and compare costs of the keyboards before committing.

It will still take a piano student effort, time, commitment and perseverance to master the piano, but Playground sessions is a high quality learning tool with excellent tuition covering most of the necessary skills and techniques. With a huge repertoire of lessons and songs, it makes a worthwhile investment.

Click here to visit Playground sessions.

 

Featured Posts

The Four Chords…

Having a system when learning the piano…

If I had to choose one course…

Motivating yourself to practice the piano…

“Every master was once a disaster” – T Harv Eker…

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Copyright
  • Terms
  • Sitemap

Copyright © 2023 · Beautiful Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT